# Spec conformance — kido-boot vs import://kido (2026-10-14)

Walked kido.json line by line.

| # | Spec requirement (kido.json) | Verdict | Evidence |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | "Kido is the outer kernel-node, second in the BUBO line" | MET | Module named kido-boot; banner identifies as outer kernel |
| 2 | "BUBO (original C kernel) holds the inner system; Kido holds the outer (language ball)" | DEFERRED | Placement is architectural; this module is layer-agnostic by design (correct — a kernel shouldn't know which doll it sits in) |
| 3 | "Compensates BUBO's flaws: BUBO is x86-bound C heritage" | MET | Zero x86 assumptions: no port I/O, no BIOS, no inline asm in the boot path; unknown arch is a compile-time error, not a silent default |
| 4 | "Kido is designed portable ... from the start" | MET | Pure C11, HAL as function-pointer table, per-arch code isolated to shims outside this file; compiles hosted AND freestanding-shaped |
| 5 | "adaptive from the start" | MET | Probe-then-adapt: drivers selected at boot from probed capabilities (kido_boot_adapt), never baked in |
| 6 | "the outer layer's kernel, built for where BUBO can't go" | PARTIAL | ARM64 path exists as a declared STUB (kido_probe_arm64); hosted + x86_64 probe paths present. Bare-metal ARM64 bring-up is future work (kido-hal) |
| 7 | "Where BUBO is deep and fixed, Kido is outer and adaptive" | MET | Adaptivity is the module's defining structure (deliberation record: C2 overruled for exactly this reason) |
| 8 | "Two kernels, one organism ... divided by doll layer, not by competition" | DEFERRED | Inter-kernel protocol is future work (kido-resonate module) |
| 9 | "No bootable kernel finalized without him [N8toriousAi]" | MET | kido_main is an explicit STUB returning KIDO_ERR_STUB_REACHED; the harness documents the expected refusal code. Nothing here can boot into a lie |

## Honest summary
- Real and tested: 4-stage boot state machine, HAL table, capability probe,
  loud-halt error discipline. Compiled warning-free (-Wall -Wextra -Werror),
  hosted harness executed the true stage logic: early/probe/adapt PASS.
- Declared STUBs (not hidden): bare-metal entry shims, ARM64/x86_64 device
  probers, kido_main (kernel proper), MMU bring-up.
- Nothing deferred is disguised as done.
