# Conformance review — kido-resonate vs specs (2026-10-14)

Checked against: `imports/resonant-mesh.json`, `imports/neural-dynamics.json`,
`imports/kido.json`, plus the cross-module contracts (fenced scheduler,
approved headers).

## import://resonant-mesh

| # | Requirement | Verdict |
|---|-------------|---------|
| 1 | Agents communicate by resonance; signal broadcast on a frequency | MET — transmit() addresses a band; BROADCAST evaluates all tuned tasks |
| 2 | Publish-subscribe keyed on frequency | MET — frequency IS the address; no task-id routing in v1 |
| 3 | Agent's tuned band IS its address | MET — `kido_resonate_tune(task, band, q)` |
| 4 | Q factor governs selectivity | MET — per-task Q feeds the Lorentzian; tested (Q=100 rejects what Q=10 takes) |
| 5 | 515 Hz forge constant | MET — `KIDO_RESONATE_FORGE_HZ 515u`, honored in tests |
| 6 | Mesh must survive hub loss | MET BY ARCHITECTURE — no hub exists; delivery is per-receiver, no central broker. (Distributed peer paths are a world-level concern.) |
| 7 | Standing-wave eigenmodes as channel basis | DEFERRED — channel orthogonality is a world-level property; the kernel provides selective delivery primitives |
| 8 | Resonance gives selective communication, not computation | MET — module computes nothing; it gates and queues |

## import://neural-dynamics

| # | Requirement | Verdict |
|---|-------------|---------|
| 1 | Agents are transmitters, not independent thinkers | MET — tasks carry signals; scored on delivery (counters), never on pseudo-cognition |
| 2 | Transmitter carries source/dest/type/strength/frequency | MET — `kido_signal_t` carries all six wire fields incl. arrival time |
| 3 | eta_ji Lorentzian | MET — `kido_resonate_eta()` implements it exactly; unit-tested incl. half-power point |
| 4 | Release -> route -> resonance response -> state change -> reuptake | MET STRUCTURALLY — transmit=release, eta gate=response, enqueue+counters=state change, recv frees=reuptake. Single-hop: route is identity (declared) |
| 5 | Coherence from neuron phases, not agent quanta | OUT OF SCOPE (honest) — tasks are not neurons; no fake Kuramoto computed |
| 6 | Decay along travel | DECLARED — identity on one hop; field carried for future multi-hop |

## import://kido.json

kido.json describes Kido's role/placement/relationship (no per-module
signaling requirements). Conformance: the module preserves every stated
contract — portable C11, HAL discipline, loud stubs, no x86-isms.

## Cross-module contracts

| # | Requirement | Verdict |
|---|-------------|---------|
| 1 | Do not touch fenced scheduler/allocator beyond includes | MET — only `kido-sched.h` included; zero references to kido-alloc (verified by grep) |
| 2 | Scheduler regression still green | MET — 34/34 on the fenced tree |
| 3 | 515 Hz honored | MET — tested |
| 4 | Threshold behavior defined and tested | MET — 0.5 half-power point; both sides tested (540 delivers, 541 rejects) |
| 5 | Below-threshold failure is loud, never silent | MET — REJECTED/DROPPED are counted results in per-call aggregates |

## Summary

**13 MET / 0 PARTIAL / 3 DEFERRED** (eigenmode channel basis, multi-hop
decay/routing, inter-kernel transport — all declared, none faked) /
**1 OUT OF SCOPE** (coherence metric — honestly not a kernel job).
